Welcome aboard!

We invite you to escape to paradise and experience the next best thing to dining in the Caribbean! Our friendly crew looks forward to guiding you on a culinary tour of delicious eats and tantalizing tropical drinks as you relax to the beat of steel drums.

Whether you’re joining us for a refreshing cocktail and savory appetizer, winding down with a decadent dessert and cappuccino, or diving into one of our signature entrees, you are sure to experience the feel of the islands with every sip and every bite. Our culinary team will delight your taste buds with exquisite signature entrees such as Lobster-N-Seafood Fra Diavolo, Seafood Provencale, Lobster & Crab Mac N’ Cheese, Gorgonzola Chicken, and Filet Mignon in a red wine reduction, portabella mushrooms, and crispy onion straws. Our chef’s specialty is Fresh Roasted Prime Rib of Beef au jus…succulent and cut to order: and Jumbo Lobster Tails…oh so tender. And, of course, all of our juicy steaks are thick cut USDA choice and grilled to perfection!

At Captain John’s we will accommodate your every need with a touch of island flare, whether you’re enjoying a romantic dinner for two, dining out with family and friends, or celebrating with a large group. Our Private Party Room can be reserved for 6 – 60 guests and is perfect for any occasion…Rehearsal Dinners, Anniversaries, Birthdays, Graduations, Proms, Corporate Meetings, or Social Functions. With group bookings of 20+ guests, we will make your party even more fun with a Free Shrimp Appetizer and Party Beads for all!

At Captain John’s, we are all about Good friends, Great food, and Great times! So bring along your friends, indulge in great food, and keep the great times going! Join us for an escape to paradise…experience Captain John’s.

Your hosts,

Elaine & Andy

Captain John's

1424 Main St.
Sylvan Beach NY, 13157
Call: 315 762-9949
Text: 315 264-1517